Our team at Sleep Foundation conducts extensive hands-on tests for each mattress to provide you with the most reliable, data-driven recommendations and reviews. Below are key guidelines that inform our testing methodology:
Our testers lie on the surface of each mattress to evaluate factors such as contouring and support. We also use specialized tools to measure performance criteria like pressure relief, heat retention, and motion isolation.
We test each mattress using various sleep positions to observe whether a mattress is better suited for side, back, or stomach sleeping. We roll around the surface and sit on the edges to gauge ease of movement and perimeter support.
We have tested hundreds of mattresses and bring years of experience in the mattress industry to the test lab. Our testing team covers a wide range of sleep preferences, sleep positions, and body types. This helps us represent as many sleeper types as possible in our reviews.
Excellent motion isolation for those who share a bed
Side sleepers over 230 pounds, back sleepers over 130 pounds, and stomach sleepers of all weights may sink in too deeply to maintain good posture
Limited edge support may make it challenging for some individuals to sit or sleep along the perimeter
Deep, close hug makes movement more difficult, which can impede position changes and sexual activity
Puffy is a sleep product company founded in 2016. While the company also produces bed frames, smart beds, and bedding, it is best known for its mattress line. The Puffy Monarch Mattress — previously known as the Puffy Diamond — is the brand’s luxury model.
Other options in the line include the Puffy Cloud, the Puffy Lux, and the Puffy Royal. All have a medium (5) feel. The Cloud is an affordably priced all-foam model, and the Lux and Royal are hybrid models with upgraded features.
The Monarch is the most advanced and high-profile model in the line, measuring 16 inches thick. It is also the plushest, with a medium soft (4) feel. This model incorporates several premium materials and features, including alpaca wool, memory foam, and zoned support.
We’ll break down how the Puffy Monarch Mattress performed in our in-house tests, explain its construction, and assess what type of sleepers might benefit from the model.
Let us help you find the perfect bed
Answer a few questions to find the right mattress for your unique needs
Please select all options
Sleeping Style and Body Weight
Puffy Monarch
Sleeper Type
Under 130 lbs
130-230 lbs
Above 230 lbs
Side Sleepers
Under 130 lbs
9/10
130-230 lbs
8/10
Above 230 lbs
7/10
Back Sleepers
Under 130 lbs
8.5/10
130-230 lbs
7.5/10
Above 230 lbs
6.5/10
Stomach Sleepers
Under 130 lbs
7.5/10
130-230 lbs
6.5/10
Above 230 lbs
5.5/10
Side Sleepers
The Puffy Monarch’s medium soft (4) feel and plush comfort system are well suited to most side sleepers. Side sleepers typically prioritize pressure relief because their shoulders and hips tend to dig into the surface more than other parts of their bodies. The Puffy Monarch provides exceptional pressure relief, molding to a side sleeper’s shoulder and hip to redistribute their weight and ease pressure.
Most side sleepers under 230 pounds experience a good balance of contouring and support on the Puffy Monarch. Those over 230 pounds are likely to sink in a bit more deeply around their hips and shoulders, which may negatively affect their posture.
Back Sleepers
Since back sleepers generally need more support and less contouring than side sleepers, the Puffy Monarch isn’t ideal for most who favor this position. Despite its zoned support, a back sleeper’s hips may sink in a little too deeply, potentially straining their lower back.
Those under 130 pounds are likely to get enough support to sleep comfortably. However, back sleepers over 130 pounds may notice more significant sagging around their hips, which may contribute to discomfort.
Stomach Sleepers
Stomach sleepers need the most support to keep their spines in alignment, which the Puffy Monarch’s medium soft (4) feel and thick comfort system are unlikely to provide. While the mattress has zoned support, it may be difficult for stomach sleepers to relax their muscles as they try to maintain good posture, and sagging around their midsections could strain their lower backs.
A few stomach sleepers under 130 pounds may get the support they need, but most stomach sleepers of all weights would benefit from more support.
Mattress Performance
In addition to the hands-on feedback from our team, we conduct a number of quantitative tests in our Test Lab. The below ratings are based on the experience of our testers.
Motion Isolation
7.5/10
In our tests, the Puffy Monarch Mattress’ exceptional motion isolation stood out among hybrid models. Its thick, seven-layer comfort system absorbs virtually all vibrations, preventing them from traveling across the mattress surface. The bed’s pocketed coil core also helps it prevent motion transfer.
For sleepers who awaken easily when their partner changes positions, this strong motion isolation could be a selling point. Most individuals are unlikely to notice movement on the Puffy Monarch if their partner tosses and turns or gets up during the night.
Pressure Relief
8/10
Thanks to its thick comfort system and medium soft (4) feel, our testers found that the Puffy Monarch Mattress offers notable pressure relief. The alpaca wool and fiber layers cushion the surface, while the polyfoam, latex, and memory foam layers mold to the sleeper’s body to limit pressure buildup. Additionally, a layer of zoned polyfoam provides variable support for more targeted contouring.
Side sleepers under 230 pounds are particularly likely to benefit from the Puffy Monarch’s pressure relief. By redistributing their weight, the mattress reduces pressure buildup around their hips and shoulders, which is a frequent cause of discomfort for side sleepers.
Temperature Control
8.5/10
Compared to other hybrid models, the Puffy Monarch Mattress regulates temperatures moderately well. Because of their breathable cores, hybrid models often remain at a neutral temperature throughout the night. The Puffy Monarch’s alpaca wool layer, perforated latex layer, and coil core encourage air circulation to reduce heat retention. However, the polyfoam and memory foam layers may hold some lingering body heat.
For most sleepers, the Puffy Monarch’s temperature regulation should more than suffice. However, hot sleepers may notice mild heat retention.
Edge Support
7.5/10
The Puffy Monarch Mattress lacks the edge support common in hybrid mattresses. Because its comfort system is quite thick, sleepers sink in deeply before reaching the support system. High-density foam wraps around the perimeter of the coil core for extra reinforcement, but our testers found that the comfort system’s significant compression may still create a sensation of instability.
Sleepers who share their bed with a partner could feel that this restricts the usable surface area since they’re likely to feel more secure closer to the center of the bed. Getting into or out of bed may also be more challenging if you feel unstable sitting along the perimeter.
Ease of Movement
8.5/10
Since the Puffy Monarch is a medium soft (4) model with a thick, conforming comfort system, our testers noted that it isn’t as easy to move on as most firmer hybrid models. Most sleepers sink in relatively deeply, impeding movement. The comfort system also retains a body impression for a moment when the sleeper moves, which may further inhibit position changes. While the coil core adds a bit of bounce, the plush comfort system limits the mattress’ overall responsiveness.
Sleepers who change positions frequently or experience mobility issues may feel like their motion is limited when sleeping on the Puffy Monarch.
Off-Gassing
9/10
Like any model that contains synthetic materials, the Puffy Monarch may emit off-gassing odors after you unpack it. Off-gassing occurs when a mattress releases volatile organic compounds (VOCs), which are a standard byproduct of manufacturing foam.
The Puffy Monarch’s hybrid design allows enough airflow to help any odors dissipate relatively quickly. Depending on how well-ventilated your room is, most smells should air out within 72 hours.
The Puffy Monarch is a luxury hybrid model with a medium soft (4) feel. At 16 inches thick, this high-profile mattress is likely to require deep pocket sheets.
A quilted fabric Euro-top cushions the surface, with layers of alpaca wool and fiber designed for plushness and temperature regulation. Next, a layer of memory foam cradles the sleeper’s body, and a layer of polyfoam provides extra cushioning. A 1-inch latex layer enhances air circulation and pushback. Another 2-inch layer of memory foam adds deeper contouring, while a zoned 3-inch polyfoam layer adds targeted support.
The mattress core uses 7.5 inches of pocketed coils for bounce and breathability. High-density foam wraps around the perimeter of the core to enhance the edge support and stabilize the surface. Finally, a grippy base cover helps prevent the mattress from shifting.
The mattress’ foam is CertiPUR-US certified, meaning a third party verifies that the material meets content and emissions standards.
As a luxury model, the Puffy Monarch Mattress carries a higher-than-average price tag. Because of its high-profile, multilayer design, it costs more than most mattresses to manufacture, which is reflected in the price-point. While this may deter some budget shoppers, it may be worth the investment for shoppers seeking an especially plush mattress.
The Puffy Monarch comes in twin XL, queen, king, California king, and split king sizes. Twin and full sizes are not available at this time.
The Puffy Monarch Mattress is sold through the official Puffy website. It’s also available through select third-party brick-and-mortar retailers, though shipping and trial policies vary.
Shipping
Puffy ships free to addresses within all 50 U.S. states. Most mattresses arrive within two to five business days via FedEx. The Puffy Monarch arrives compressed, wrapped in plastic, and rolled in a box. It is delivered to the customer’s door, and they are responsible for bringing it inside and carefully unpackaging it. The mattress should fully expand within two hours.
Additional Services
Puffy does not currently offer White Glove delivery or old mattress removal.
Sleep Trial
When ordered directly through the company’s website, the Puffy Monarch Mattress comes with a 101-night sleep trial. After trying the mattress for at least 14 nights, you can contact Puffy to initiate a return for the remainder of the trial period. The company will arrange the removal and donation of your unwanted mattress and issue a full refund of the purchase price.
Warranty
The Puffy Monarch Mattress comes with a limited lifetime warranty that covers visible indentations and sagging over 1.5 inches deep, manufacturing flaws in the cover zipper, and physical flaws in the cover’s construction. Damage due to improper use or abuse does not qualify for coverage. If an eligible defect arises, Puffy will replace the mattress at no charge.
Still have questions?
Our product experts have extensive experience testing just about every sleep product on the market. Send an email to [email protected] or call us at (877) 672-8966 with your questions and we’ll help you find exactly what you’re looking for.
