Zenhaven vs. PlushBeds Botanical Bliss Mattress Comparison

If you’re in the market for an environmentally friendly mattress made with natural materials, then there’s a good chance you’ve heard of the Zenhaven and the Plushbeds Botanical Bliss.

The Zenhaven by Saatva is an all-latex mattress made from Dunlop latex, which has a reputation for gentle contouring and targeted pressure relief. The mattress is flippable, featuring a different firmness level on each side. As with all Saatva-made mattresses, the Zenhaven comes with free White Glove delivery and old mattress removal.

The PlushBeds Botanical Bliss is also made with Dunlop latex instead of Talalay latex. The mattress is available in three different profiles and two different firmness levels. The top two layers can also be exchanged with each other to alter the feel of the mattress.

Zenhaven and Plushbeds are both solid choices for shoppers who value sustainably made products at affordable prices. We’ll go more in detail about the design of each mattress, comparing common metrics like temperature regulation, motion isolation, and pressure relief. We’ll also examine practical details on pricing, shipping, and other policies to help you decide between the two.

Quick Look

We’ve worked hard to show you the best mattresses for you. Check out our full mattress guides listed below!

The Zenhaven has an average profile and comes in all the standard mattress sizes as well as split king size. Since the mattress is flippable, both iterations have the same size, height, and weight. Saatva offers free White Glove delivery for the Zenhaven. However, as with most latex mattresses, the Zenhaven is quite heavy. This may make it more difficult to flip if your firmness preferences change down the road.

PlushBeds offers significantly more options with the Botanical Bliss, which comes in a choice of three profiles. The 9-inch model will be easier to maneuver, while the 12-inch model may offer more support for individuals over 230 pounds. Those who order the 12-inch model should note that it is quite a bit heavier than the average mattress, which may make it difficult to set up and transport.

PlushBeds also offers more sizes than Zenhaven, with all the standard mattress sizes plus split queen, split king, and split California king. This makes it feasible for couples to personalize their firmness levels, even with a queen size mattress.

Sizing and Weight Options

Practical considerations to take into account when mattress shopping include size, height, and weight.

Most mattresses come in six standard sizes: twin, twin XL, full, queen, king, and California king. Some manufacturers also offer split king sizes, which allow shoppers to choose a different firmness level for each side of the bed. If you’re planning on keeping your existing foundation or bed frame, it’s a good idea to double-check the measurements to make sure they match up with your new mattress.

The height of a mattress should be appropriate for the space you’re working with, whether a gigantic bedroom or a cramped RV. Additionally, choosing a mattress and foundation that sit at a comfortable height can help make it easier to get in and out of bed. Mattresses that are much taller than average may need deep-pocket fitted sheets.

A heavy mattress can be inconvenient for those who have trouble lifting heavy objects, or who plan on moving the mattress after it is set up. Mattress weight takes on special relevance with flippable mattresses, as it determines how easy it is to flip the mattress. Flippable latex mattresses often have thin-to-average profiles in order to reduce their overall weight.

Construction and Materials Comparison

The durability and comfort of a mattress are determined by its design, as well as the quality and type of materials used to construct it.

Common materials used in the top layers of a mattress include polyfoam, memory foam, latex, micro-coils, and padding materials such as cotton or wool. Since these are the layers that come into direct contact with the sleeper, they must be able to relieve pressure points and provide a comfortable sleeping surface. This is a direct feature in making a mattress good for back pain.

The bottom layers of a mattress form the support core, and usually include materials like firm latex, high-density polyfoam, or pocketed coils. These materials lend robust stability to the bed and help keep the spine on an even plane.

Most mattresses fall into one of the following five broad categories depending on their basic design: innerspring, hybrid, all-foam, airbed, and latex. The Zenhaven and the PlushBeds Botanical Bliss are both latex mattresses, meaning they feature latex in the support cores as well as the comfort layers. Latex is a durable material known for providing above-average responsiveness and temperature regulation.

Zenhaven

The flippable Zenhaven mattress is made with four layers of latex in total. Both sides have a quilted organic cotton cover. This is followed by a 1-inch fire barrier made with organic New Zealand wool. Together, these materials provide a breathable, moisture-wicking sleep surface that helps keep a neutral temperature throughout the night.

All four layers are made of natural Dunlop latex, which feels lighter and more buoyant than Dunlop latex. The layers have varying firmnesses on each side.

Most popular with side sleepers, the medium soft side has 1.5 inches of soft latex. This layer features different-sized pincore holes that enhance airflow and divide the surface of the mattress into five zones for targeted pressure relief and lumbar support. Beneath this layer is a 3-inch transitional layer of slightly firmer latex.

More popular with back and stomach sleepers, the firm side has a top layer made with 1.5 inches of zoned, slightly firmer latex. This is followed by a 3-inch transitional layer of firm latex. Combined, the two transitional layers form a sturdy support core for both sides of the mattress.

PlushBeds Botanical Bliss

The PlushBeds Botanical Bliss comes in three different profiles: 9-inch, 10-inch, and 12-inch. All Botanical Bliss mattresses have a breathable 1-inch organic cotton cover padded with up to 10 pounds of organic New Zealand wool.

The rest of the mattress is made with Dunlop latex, which generally has a reputation for being denser than Talalay latex. Due to the way it’s manufactured, it’s possible to make organic-certified Dunlop latex, something that is impossible with Talalay latex. The Botanical Bliss mattress holds certifications from the Global Organic Latex Standard (GOLS), and the cotton and wool are certified organic by the Global Organic Textile Standard (GOTS).

PlushBeds customers can choose from two firmness levels, medium firm or firm. The Medium 9-inch and 12-inch models have 2 inches of soft Dunlop latex over 3 inches of medium soft Dunlop latex, while the Firm 9-inch and 12-inch models have 2 inches of medium Dunlop latex over 3 inches of medium firm Dunlop latex. The top layer of the 10-inch mattresses is 3 inches thick.

The Medium models allow closer contouring that is best-suited to the majority of sleepers, especially those who primarily sleep on their side. The Firm models are more popular with those who sleep on their stomach or who weigh more than 230 pounds. For all of the Botanical Bliss models, sleepers can manually create a slightly firmer surface by swapping the top two layers.

The 9-inch and 10-inch mattresses have a support core made with 3 inches of Dunlop latex. This layer has a medium firmness in the Medium models, and is extra firm in the Firm models. The 12-inch mattress has a dual-layer support core. It’s composed of 3 inches of medium latex and 3 inches of medium firm latex in the Medium models, and 3 inches of medium firm latex and 3 inches of extra firm latex in the Firm models.

In-Depth Ratings

There are certain key metrics that make a significant difference to the feel of a mattress, such as temperature regulation, motion isolation, and ease of movement. These may be more or less important to you depending on your body type, sleeping style, environment, personal preference, whether or not you sleep with a partner, and other factors. Understanding which ones you value the most can help you make an educated decision when buying a mattress.

Durability
The average mattress lasts approximately 6 or 7 years before it starts to sag or develops noticeable body indentations. Once it reaches this point, it’s no longer able to provide healthy support for your body, and it will need to be replaced. The durability of a mattress is primarily influenced by the type and quality of its materials. Natural latex mattresses tend to be the most durable, and can often last several years longer than other types of mattresses if properly cared for.

Motion Isolation
For people who share the bed, choosing a mattress that absorbs motion is key to getting a good night’s sleep. Materials that conform closely to the sleeper generally do best at adapting to the sleeper’s movements without letting motion transfer across the bed. As it’s typically plusher and less dense, Talalay latex usually outperforms Dunlop latex on motion isolation.

Sex
Bouncy mattresses such as latex or hybrid models facilitate movement and make it easier to switch positions. For these reasons, the common consensus is that a bouncy mattress is best for sex. Some couples may also want to consider factors like edge support, temperature regulation, and noise when choosing a mattress for sex.

Temperature Neutrality
People who naturally overheat or who live in warm climates should try to choose a mattress that maintains a neutral temperature. This can be accomplished by using breathable materials, by using cooling technology, or by designing the mattress to incorporate room for airflow.

Latex, and particularly Talalay latex, is a naturally breathable material that resists heat retention better than most synthetic foams. Many latex mattresses are also aerated with pincore holes to increase air circulation.

Pressure Relief
One of the main functions of a mattress is to provide pressure relief. Some mattresses are so firm that they cause pressure points at parts that commonly dig into the mattress, such as the hips and shoulders. Other mattresses are so plush that they allow heavier body parts like the hips to sink in too far, putting strain on the spinal column. The ideal is to find something in between that provides an adequate amount of cushioning and support for your body type and sleeping position.

Off-gassing
Mattresses made with synthetic foams such as memory foam and polyfoam are known to emit off-gassing smells when they are first unboxed. These are caused by volatile organic compounds (VOCs) produced during the manufacturing process. By contrast, natural latex mattresses that contain no synthetic foams, flame retardants, or adhesives should have barely any odor at all. If anything, some customers may notice a faint rubbery scent from a new latex mattress.

Ease of Movement
Close-conforming and unresponsive mattresses can lead to the feeling of being trapped in quicksand. Even though latex does contour to some extent, it’s naturally springy and quick to regain its shape when pressure is lifted. This means it doesn’t impede movement as memory foam can, making it a good choice for combination sleepers.

Edge Support
The edges of a mattress tend to sag under pressure, which can cause feelings of roll-off when sitting on or sleeping near the edge of the bed. Edge support goes hand-in-hand with the firmness of the mattress, with plush mattresses allowing more sink.

It also depends on whether or not the mattress has any special reinforcement around the perimeter, such as stronger coils or a high-density polyfoam border. People who sleep with a partner should consider a mattress with strong edges that allows each person full use of the bed.

Zenhaven

PlushBeds Botanical Bliss

Prices and Sizing

Mattress prices vary widely, and the reason for this may not be clear at first glance. Apart from the obvious variables such as the type of mattress and the brand, some of the factors that influence the price of a mattress include the quality of the materials and the certifications they carry, such as organic; the country of manufacture; and the number of layers and the total height of the mattress. Additionally, special features such as proprietary foams and shipping and sleep trial policies may also influence the cost.

Higher-quality mattresses are usually more durable, and many people rightly assume that it’s worth paying a little more for a mattress that will last longer. That said, a high price doesn’t necessarily guarantee a good product, so it also pays to do your research before buying.

Mattress companies are known to run such frequent promotions that it’s become a rarity to pay full price for a mattress. Moreover, the invention of mattress-in-a-box shipping has drastically cut down overhead costs for mattress manufacturers. These savings have been passed along to consumers. The result is that the mattress industry today is able to offer excellent value for money no matter what your budget.

Zenhaven

PlushBeds Botanical Bliss

Natural latex mattresses are among the most expensive models due to their complex manufacturing process and the host of certifications they tend to carry. In addition to natural latex, the Zenhaven and the Botanical Bliss also contain organic cotton and wool, which further drive up the price. Despite their use of durable and sustainable materials, the Zenhaven and the Botanical Bliss have fairly reasonable price-points compared to other natural latex mattresses.

The Zenhaven and the Botanical Bliss are similarly priced, with the Botanical Bliss varying in price depending on the height. The 10-inch Zenhaven costs slightly more than the equivalent 10-inch Botanical Bliss. White Glove delivery is also built into the price of the Zenhaven.

Trials, Warranty, and Delivery

Shipping

The majority of mattresses sold online are shipped shrink-wrapped and compressed as a mattress-in-a-box, a relatively cheap shipping method that has allowed companies to dramatically cut overhead costs. Mattress-in-a-box shipping is usually offered free in the contiguous U.S. Customers in Hawaii, Alaska, or international locations may have to pay shipping fees.

Mattresses ship via FedEx Ground or UPS Ground, and usually arrive at the customer’s home within a matter of days. Mattresses that are made to order may take longer to ship.

Some companies offer the option of White Glove delivery, which includes setup of the mattress in the room of choice and sometimes old mattress removal as well. This service usually incurs an extra fee, and may not be available in all locations.

Zenhaven Shipping Policy

The Zenhaven mattress comes with free White Glove delivery and old mattress removal in the contiguous U.S. Customers in Hawaii and Alaska should contact Saatva for delivery options.

PlushBeds Botanical Bliss Shipping Policy

The PlushBeds Botanical Bliss ships for free as a mattress in a box in the contiguous U.S. Customers can work with PlushBeds to organize setup or old mattress removal through a third-party provider for an extra fee. Customers outside the contiguous U.S. should contact the company for a shipping quote.

Returns

Buying a mattress sight unseen can be nerve-wracking. To reduce the risk to customers, most companies offer a sleep trial. Lasting a few months to as much as a year, a sleep trial gives the customer ample time to try out the mattress in their own home before committing to the purchase.

Customers who decide they don’t like the mattress can contact the company, who will arrange for pickup and provide a full refund. Returned mattresses are usually donated to charity or recycled. Some companies may charge a handling fee for returns.

Zenhaven Sleep Trial

Saatva offers customers 365 nights to try the Zenhaven mattress. During this time, those who don’t like the mattress can return it for a full refund minus a $99 handling fee.

PlushBeds Botanical Bliss Sleep Trial

The PlushBeds Botanical Bliss mattress comes with a 100-night sleep trial for customers in the contiguous U.S. PlushBeds asks that customers sleep on the mattress for a full 30 nights before initiating a return. Those who return the mattress before 30 nights are up, or customers who wish to keep free accessories included with the mattress purchase, will pay a $99 fee. During the sleep trial, customers can opt to receive a comfort exchange instead of returning the mattress. In this case, customers send in the top latex layer to PlushBeds, who will send out a softer or firmer latex layer that can be inserted into the mattress.

Warranties

Once the sleep trial is over, customers are still protected by a warranty. Should a mattress display defects during the warranty period, the company will repair or replace the mattress. In the case of a prorated warranty, customers may be responsible for a portion of the return or repair costs after a set period of time has elapsed. Some companies also charge a handling fee for warranty claims.

Warranties are designed to cover the consumer against unexpected manufacturing and workmanship defects, and usually extend to permanent body indentations, splitting or cracking of the foam, or flaws in the cover. They are usually void for mattresses that have been misused, abused, or used without a proper foundation.

Zenhaven Warranty

The Zenhaven is protected by a lifetime warranty against defects including body impressions of at least 0.75 inch. During the first two years, customers will receive a new mattress free of charge to replace a defective one. After the first two years, mattresses will be repaired and re-covered for a $149 handling fee. Starting in the third year, in lieu of a repair, customers can also choose to keep the defective mattress and purchase a new one for a prorated discount plus a handling fee.

PlushBeds Botanical Bliss Warranty

PlushBeds provides a 25-year pro-rated warranty against defects including body impressions of at least 1.5 inches. Defective mattresses will be repaired or replaced at PlushBeds’ discretion during the first ten years. After this period, the company will either repair the mattress for a handling cost, or replace it at a prorated charge. Customers may be responsible for return shipping and handling costs.