Saatva vs. Tempur-Pedic Mattress Comparison

Overall Rating

9.4

Saatva Classic

Bottom Line

Three firmness options feature innovative microcoils for a unique source of support and bounce.

Check Price on Saatva.com

Buy more, save more. Up to $500 off.

Full Mattress Review

VS

Overall Rating

8.0

Tempur-Pedic TEMPUR-Adapt

Bottom Line

A high-performance mattress from Tempur-Pedic that comforts and supports back sleepers.

Check Price on Tempurpedic.com

$2,199 from Tempur-Pedic (queen)

Full Mattress Review

Saatva and Tempur-Pedic both have excellent reputations, but the mattresses they manufacture vary in construction, pricing, performance, policies, and which sleepers are likely to find them most comfortable.

Tempur-Pedic is one of the biggest names in the industry, and it is well known for its wide range of high-quality memory foam mattresses. While each mattress that the company manufactures incorporates proprietary memory foam in some way, Tempur-Pedic also produces hybrid models, which include innerspring coils and other materials.

Saatva focuses on producing models with coil support systems. All of the models we’ll cover also use memory foam, polyfoam, and/or latex for additional cradling.

We’ll provide important details about Saatva and Tempur-Pedic models to help shoppers pick the right company and mattress for their needs and preferences.

Sizing Options

Size and weight can influence the comfort and convenience of a mattress, so shoppers shouldn’t overlook these details.

The size directly impacts how much room you’ll have to move around and whether or not the mattress will fit on your existing bed frame. While a twin size mattress might be good for children, most adults prefer a larger bed. If you’re buying a mattress for you and your partner, chances are you’ll want a queen size or larger.

Other factors to consider are the weight and height of a mattress. Heavier mattresses are more difficult to move around, but they can also feel more firmly positioned on the frame. Additionally, if the bed is too low to the ground or too high, it may be challenging to get into or out of, especially for those with mobility issues. Shoppers should also note that high-profile models typically require deep pocket sheets, so you may need to save room in your budget for new bedding.

Since the weights and heights of Tempur-Pedic and Saatva mattresses vary, determining what measurements you prefer could help you decide.

Both Saatva and Tempur-Pedic produce a wide range of mattress sizes. In addition to the six standard sizes, both companies also offer split king and split California king size options.

One big difference between these two companies is the height of their products. While Tempur-Pedic offers mattress heights between 11 and 13 inches, Saatva has mattresses up to 15.5 inches thick. This might give Saatva an edge with shoppers who prefer high-profile models.

The Saatva mattresses tend to be a bit heavier than Tempur-Pedic’s, and this is likely due to the differences in both height and the materials used. After all, a thicker mattress is invariably going to have more materials, which leads to more weight.

The thicker a mattress is, the better it typically rates for individuals over 230 pounds. This is because higher profile models usually have more generous comfort and support systems, so they’re less likely to bottom out under a sleeper’s weight. The Saatva HD was designed specifically for people in this weight range, earning high marks from side, back, and stomach sleepers who need a little extra support.

While Tempur-Pedic offers a wider variety of mattresses, they focus mainly on their memory foam with only a few hybrid options. Since most of the company’s mattresses are a bit thinner than Saatva, they may be better suited to sleepers under 230 pounds.

Construction and Materials Comparison

Both Tempur-Pedic and Saatva produce a wide range of mattress models. While most of their products use similar materials, there are notable differences between each model.

Tempur-Pedic offers primarily all-foam mattresses, which are constructed with memory foam, polyfoam, or a combination of both materials. This type of mattress is usually best for back pain, pressure relief, and motion isolation.

Saatva and Tempur-Pedic both sell hybrid models. Hybrid mattresses combine multiple types of material for comfort and support. Coils, polyfoam, and memory foam are the most common materials in hybrid models. This combination of materials usually contributes to enhanced temperature regulation, bounce, and edge support.

We will cover the main mattress models manufactured by Saatva and Tempur-Pedic.

Saatva

Saatva’s mattresses typically feature a pocketed coil core, polyfoam, memory foam, and/or latex. We’ll analyze the construction of the company’s four main models.

The Saatva Classic

• Two layers of coils
• 3-inch Euro-top made with polyfoam, fiber, and Dacron
• Foam rails edging
• Spinal zone technology

The Saatva Classic is the brand’s flagship model. It could be classified as either a hybrid or innerspring mattress.

A 3-inch Euro-top with polyfoam, fiber, and Dacron cushions the surface of the bed. Next, a thin layer of memory foam near the lumbar region is designed to promote proper spinal alignment. A 4-inch comfort layer of 14.5-gauge pocketed coils provides contouring and responsiveness. The core is constructed of 13-gauge hourglass coils to resist sagging. High-density foam wraps around the perimeter for enhanced edge support.

This model is available in three firmness levels: soft, medium firm, and firm. It also comes in two thicknesses: 11.5 inches and 14.5 inches.

The Saatva Classic’s balanced performance earns it high marks in most categories.

The Saatva HD

• Five-zone Talalay latex layer
• 1.5-inch memory foam comfort layer
• 3-inch Euro-top with polyfoam
• 6-inch support base with 12.5-gauge steel coils
• Foam rails lining the edge of the mattress

The Saatva HD is designed specifically for larger individuals. A Euro-top with polyfoam cushions the surface of the bed. The comfort system consists of 3 layers: 1.5 inches of Talalay latex, 1.5 inches of memory foam, and 2 inches of polyfoam. The latex layer is zoned to promote healthy sleep posture, and all three layers contour to the body for pressure relief.

A 6-inch, 12.5-gauge coil core is sturdier than the industry average to better support sleepers over 230 pounds, and a polyfoam layer serves as the base of the coil system. High-density foam rails around the sides of the bed enhance edge support.

The Saatva HD is a firm mattress especially well suited to individuals who weigh over 230 pounds. It also excels in temperature control, responsiveness, and edge support.

The Saatva Latex Hybrid

• Five-zone Talalay latex comfort layer
• 8-inch zoned coil core
• GOTS certified organic wool layer
• GOTS certified organic cotton cover

This medium firm hybrid mattress starts with a GOTS certified organic cotton cover and a GOTS certified organic wool fire barrier. Wool is also known for its strong temperature-regulating properties, so it should help insulate when the sleeper is cold and wick away excess warmth when they’re hot. Next, a 3-inch, five-zone natural Talalay latex comfort layer is designed to contour to the body while supporting proper spinal alignment. The 8-inch pocketed coil core is also zoned with sturdier springs around the edge.

If you’re looking for a bed that should hold up well, the Saatva Latex Hybrid Mattress earns high marks in durability.

The Saatva Youth Mattress

• Five-zone polyfoam comfort layer (side 1)
• High-density polyfoam comfort layer (side 2)
• 13.75-gauge steel coil core lined with polyfoam for edge support
• Organic hypoallergenic cotton cover

Growing bodies tend to need a different kind of mattress, and this youth mattress is designed to address the needs of younger sleepers with this flippable mattress. One side is designed for children ages 3 to 7, and the other side is more appropriate for kids ages 8 to 12. The firmness levels equate to medium firm and firm.

Since the mattress is two-sided, each side has its own comfort layer. The side intended for younger children has a five-zone polyfoam layer engineered to help kids maintain proper spinal alignment. The other side uses high-density polyfoam that balances contouring and breathability. A 13.75 gauge core provides support for either side, and firm polyfoam encases the outside for a more stable edge.

The Saatva Youth Mattress also has a water-resistant finish and waterproof barrier that are intended to protect the mattress against spills or other accidents.

Tempur-Pedic

Tempur-Pedic offers a wide range of mattress models, all of which include the company’s proprietary memory foam. Both all-foam and hybrid models are available.

The TEMPUR-Adapt Series

• TEMPUR-ES memory foam comfort layer
• TEMPUR transitional memory foam layer
• Polyester blend cover
• High-density polyfoam support core (all-foam)
• Pocketed coil support core encased in high-density polyfoam (hybrid)

This series of mattresses is available in all-foam and hybrid versions. Both contain a comfort layer of TEMPUR-ES memory foam and a TEMPUR transition layer to shape to the body and ease pressure buildup. The all-foam model uses a polyfoam core for support, while the hybrid mattress includes pocketed coils with foam edging. A cool-to-the-touch cover encases the mattress, and an antimicrobial treatment is intended to protect against allergens.

The TEMPUR-Adapt has a medium feel, which performs well for side sleepers. The all-foam and hybrid versions earn high marks in pressure relief, motion isolation, and durability. The hybrid performs slightly better than the all-foam in edge support, sex, and temperature regulation.

The TEMPUR-ProAdapt Series

• TEMPUR-ES memory foam comfort layer
• TEMPUR-APR memory foam transition layer
• Dual-layer SmartClimate cover with a removable outer layer
• High-density polyfoam support core (all-foam)
• Pocketed coil support core encased in high-density polyfoam (hybrid only)

The main differences between the TEMPUR-ProAdapt Series and the TEMPUR-Adapt Series are the inclusion of a removable cover designed for better temperature regulation and the addition of TEMPUR-APR memory foam. The outer layer of the cover can be zipped off and washed in a machine for convenient cleaning, and TEMPUR-APR is engineered for exceptional pressure relief.

Like the Adapt Series, mattresses in the ProAdapt Series contain a TEMPUR-ES comfort layer and either a high-density polyfoam or pocketed coil core depending on whether you select the all-foam or the hybrid version.

This model is also different from other Tempur-Pedic mattresses in that it includes three firmness options for the all-foam option: soft, medium, and firm. Much like their TEMPUR-Adapt models, these mattresses also rate very well for side sleepers.

The TEMPUR-LuxeAdapt Mattress

• High-density polyfoam support core
• TEMPUR-ES memory foam comfort layer
• TEMPUR-APR+ transition layer
• Dual-layer SmartClimate cover with a removable component

While many Tempur-Pedic models are available hybrid designs, this series is only available as an all-foam mattress. Two firmness options are available: soft and firm model.

As you might notice, there are a lot of similarities between the TEMPUR-LuxeAdapt and TEMPUR-ProAdapt Series. The main difference is the addition of TEMPUR-APR+ memory foam, which is designed to provide additional close-conforming pressure relief. Like the Adapt and the ProAdapt, the LuxeAdapt uses a TEMPUR-ES comfort layer and a high-density polyfoam core. Its combination of cradling and support is likely to appeal to side and back sleepers.

The TEMPUR-LUXEbreeze Mattress

• High-density polyfoam support core
• PureCool+ phase change material
• TEMPUR-CM+ memory foam comfort layer
• TEMPUR-APR memory foam support layer
• Removable dual-layer SmartClimate polyester cover

Much like the TEMPUR-LuxeAdapt, this model is only available as an all-foam mattress with two firmness options: soft and firm. However, there are some key differences between the two models. The TEMPUR-LUXEbreeze is crafted for temperature regulation, adding TEMPUR-CM+ and PureCool+ phase change material to the mattress. TEMPUR-CM+ is designed to allow airflow, while PureCool+ phase change material is engineered to absorb and redistribute heat for a cooling sensation.

A layer of ventilated TEMPUR-APR further enhances the circulation so that heat can dissipate, and a high-density polyfoam core supports the bed. Like the LuxeAdapt and ProAdapt, the LUXEbreeze also uses a SmartClimate Dual Cover System with an outer layer that can be removed and washed.

True to its name, this memory foam mattress performs particularly well in the temperature control category. It is designed to stay approximately 8 degrees cooler than the Adapt Series.

The TEMPUR-PRObreeze Series

• PureCool+ phase change material
• TEMPUR-CM+ memory foam comfort layer
• Dual-layer SmartClimate cover with a zip-off outer layer
• High-density polyfoam support core (all-foam)
• Pocketed coil core (hybrid)

This mattress is available as either a hybrid or an all-foam model, both of which have a medium feel. The PRObreeze is designed to stay 3 degrees cooler than the Adapt Series. Like the LUXEbreeze, it is topped with a dual-layer SmartClimate cover, the top panel of which is removable and machine washable. The PRObreeze also contains PureCool+ phase change material designed to wick away warmth.

The comfort layer consists of TEMPUR-CM+ memory foam engineered to let heat escape, and a ventilated TEMPUR layer eases the transition between the comfort system and firm core. Pocketed coils make up the support of the hybrid model, while the all-form version uses high-density polyfoam.

The PRObreeze is especially well suited to side and back sleeping, and it earns high marks for motion isolation and temperature control.

Mattress Performance Ratings

If you want to get the best bed possible, you may want to look for the product that earns the highest rating across all performance categories. However, due to the differences in how materials perform, you’re unlikely to find a mattress that excels in all aspects. Therefore, you should consider which areas are the most important for your needs and preferences so that you can prioritize.

• Durability: The more durable a mattress is, the longer it is likely to last. A mattress with a high durability rating will typically feature design elements intended to prevent sagging and indentations that could limit its lifespan, thereby enabling it to last as long or longer than most similarly constructed models. To put it simply, this rating defines the overall quality of a mattress and its potential longevity. It is also an important consideration when assessing overall value since a durable mattress may not need to be replaced as soon.
• Motion Isolation: If you’re sharing a bed with someone who moves around a lot in their sleep, your own rest may suffer. Motion isolation is how well a mattress dampens vibrations from the movements of your partner. Memory foam tends to be one of the best materials for isolating motion, so many mattresses use it in their comfort and/or transition layers. This factor is especially important for people who share a bed and sleep lightly.
• Sex: This can be an important detail for couples to consider when purchasing a mattress, as some beds provide more bounce than others. Memory foam does a great job isolating movement, which isn’t necessarily beneficial for sex, but it can add traction. Innerspring and hybrid mattresses tend to rate well due to their responsiveness. Hybrid mattresses are particularly popular with couples because they usually combine the motion isolation of foam with the bounce of springs.
• Temperature Neutrality: Some mattresses retain body heat, which can become uncomfortable throughout the night. If you tend to overheat while sleeping, you’ll probably prefer a mattress that regulates temperatures well. Breathable materials typically contribute to better temperature control since excess heat can escape. Some mattresses also contain special components, like phase change material, designed for cooling.
• Pressure Relief: While side sleepers might want softer mattresses so that their curves can sink in more, back and stomach sleepers may need something firmer to prevent their midsections from sinking in too deeply. A mattress that relieves pressure well will typically mold to the sleeper’s body and redistribute their weight to reduce pressure accumulation near wider, heavier areas, like the hips and shoulders. The ideal level of contouring should also help keep the spine well aligned.
• Off-gassing: New mattresses may emit smells related to the materials used in manufacturing. Off-gassing refers to the period of time during which odors dissipate from the mattress. In most cases, it shouldn’t take longer than 24 to 48 hours. These gases are usually not considered harmful, and many mattress companies use substances that are certified for safety.
• Ease of Movement: Ease of movement depends on the responsiveness of the materials and the firmness of the bed. A softer memory foam mattress will allow you to sink in quite a bit, which could impede your movement. Since memory foam is relatively slow to respond to changes in pressure, an impression of your body may linger for a moment after you’ve moved, which some experience as a “trapped in the bed” sensation.However, an innerspring or hybrid mattress is usually much bouncier, which can make it easier to change positions. Firmer models also typically earn higher ease of movement scores since sleepers don’t sink in as deeply.
• Edge Support: The edges of some mattresses are prone to sagging when weight is applied, which can make it more difficult to sit or sleep near the perimeter. Many models include design features that attempt to address this issue. Edge reinforcement, like sturdier coils or foam encasement along the sides, can expand the usable mattress surface by making the perimeter feel more secure.

Saatva

Tempur-Pedic

Pricing Information

The price is invariably an important factor to consider when deciding which mattress to purchase. While most buyers focus on keeping costs low, it should be noted that lower-priced mattresses may also be of lower quality. As such, it’s important to weigh performance with cost to understand which product offers the best overall value.

Pricing usually depends on the materials. Innerspring mattresses tend to be less expensive than most foam, hybrid, and latex models. Beds made with proprietary materials often carry higher price tags due to the expense of research and development.

In addition to these elements, you can also expect other details, such as size, thickness, and company policies, to impact the price of a mattress.

The Saatva mattresses have a lower average price-point. This is largely due to differences in construction. Many Saatva models contain substantial coil layers, which are often more budget-friendly than high-quality foam. Additionally, while Tempur-Pedic uses a wide array of proprietary materials exclusive to the company, Saatva relies primarily on more commonly used components also found in competing models.

There are a few other factors to consider when looking at prices, including company policies. Typically, the more expensive brands will offer longer warranties and trial periods. That isn’t the case with these two companies, as Saatva offers longer sleep trials and warranties. Both companies offer free White Glove delivery for most models.

Trial, Warranty, and Delivery

Shipping options, sleep trials, and warranties differ between companies. Understanding these policies can help you anticipate how you will receive your shipment, what options are available if you don’t like your new mattress, and whether the company will stand behind the product if a defect arises.

Shipping

There are usually two different types of shipping services provided by mattress manufacturers in the United States.

Most online mattress companies use mattress-in-a-box style shipping, which means the mattress is compressed, rolled, and delivered to the customer’s door. The owner must then move the mattress into their room of choice, unpack it, and dispose of their old mattress if they so choose.

Some companies also offer White Glove delivery, which means a team will deliver and set up your new bed. They will also often remove your old mattress and box spring and any packing materials used in transportation. This service usually costs extra, but a handful of companies include free White Glove delivery with the purchase of a new mattress.

Delivery typically takes 1 to 2 weeks in the contiguous United States and 2 to 3 weeks in Hawaii and Alaska, but this varies between companies. If you are concerned with expected shipping times, contact customer support for more information.

Saatva Shipping Policies

Saatva provides free White Glove delivery within the contiguous United States for all of its mattresses. Once your mattress is ready for delivery, a team will call to set up a 4-hour delivery window. They will bring the bed into your room of choice, remove it from its packaging, set it up, and dispose of your old mattress and foundation if you so choose.

The company does not currently deliver to Hawaii or Alaska, but it will help you work with a freight company to receive the mattress shipment. Shipping to these two states will come with an additional fee, and it will not include White Glove service.

Tempur-Pedic Shipping Policies

Most Tempur-Pedic mattresses include free White Glove delivery within the contiguous United States. A team will unpack your new bed, place it in your bedroom, remove the packing materials, and remove your old mattress and box spring on request.

A $600 surcharge applies for shipments to Hawaii and Alaska.

Sleep Trial and Returns

Many mattress manufacturers offer sleep trials that allow you to try their product for a specific amount of time and return or exchange it if you’re not satisfied. These trial periods typically last between 90 and 120 days, but some companies offer longer windows. Some companies require that the customer pay return shipping charges, handling fees, and/or restocking fees, while others help arrange for a local donation of the discarded mattress.

Most companies limit the number of trial periods per household, and the mattress must be in good condition to qualify. Additional terms and conditions may apply, so customers should read the fine print.

Saatva Sleep Trial and Return Policy

Saatva offers a 365-night in-home trial for its mattresses. There is no mandatory break-in period required, so you can return it at any time within the trial period. If you choose to return your mattress, Saatva will send a team to pick it up and deduct $99 from the total refund to cover transportation and labor.

Tempur-Pedic Sleep Trial and Return Policy

Tempur-Pedic mattresses come with a 90-night sleep trial. The company asks that you try the mattress for at least 30 nights before initiating a return. If you decide the mattress isn’t right for you, Tempur-Pedic will work with you to address the issue and accept a return if another solution cannot be found. The customer is responsible for shipping charges.

Warranty

Whenever you purchase a mattress from a reputable manufacturer or retailer, chances are that it will come with a warranty that protects against certain defects in the materials and workmanship. What qualifies as a defect, how long the coverage lasts, and whether or not you will be assessed a fee for repairs, replacements, or transportation will depend on the policy.

Warranties do not typically cover normal wear-and-tear, misuse, abuse, damage due to the use of an improper support base, or changes in personal preference. Only the original owner is eligible to make warranty claims. Since terms and conditions apply, go over the policy carefully for a full understanding of your rights and responsibilities.

Saatva Mattress Warranty

Saatva mattresses come with the brand’s standard lifetime warranty. These policies protect against defects in workmanship and materials. For the first two years, the company may elect to repair or replace a defective mattress free of charge. After that, shipping fees apply.

Saatva also offers a Fairness Replacement Option that allows you to keep your old mattress and receive a replacement at a discounted price.

Tempur-Pedic Mattress Warranty

Tempur-Pedic provides a 10-year limited warranty on its mattresses. This warranty protects against defects in the workmanship or materials, including visible indentations greater than .75 inches, flaws that cause the foam to split or crack, and issues with the cover. Tempur-Pedic will choose to either repair or replace eligible mattresses, and the owner will be responsible for shipping charges.

Still have questions? Ask our community!

Join our Sleep Care Community — a trusted hub of product specialists, sleep health professionals, and people just like you. Whether you’re searching for the perfect mattress or need expert sleep advice, we’ve got you covered. Get personalized guidance from the experts who know sleep best.