Brooklyn Bedding vs. Leesa Mattress Comparison

Overall Rating

8.4

Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid

Bottom Line

The Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid pairs multiple foams with strong coils. Three firmness options cover a wide range of sleepers.

Check Price on BrooklinBedding.com

25% off storewide/sitewide. Code: GIFT25

Full Mattress Review

VS

Overall Rating

8.0

Leesa Original

Bottom Line

The Leesa Original comes in all-foam and hybrid versions, pairing the hug of memory foam with more breathable layers.

Check Price on Leesa.com

20% off mattresses + 2 free pillows with purchase, 15% off kids’ mattresses, and 20% off bases and bedding

Full Mattress Review

Brooklyn Bedding and Leesa are popular mattress companies that focus on providing American-made products using high-quality materials. Their mattresses are made-to-order to limit the time spent in a warehouse. Both companies compress and box each mattress and ship it directly to the customer’s door for your convenience and affordability.

Brooklyn Bedding offers seven main mattress models. Each is available in the six standard options and split California king. Many are also available in less common sizes, like Olympic queen and RV king. Several Brooklyn Bedding models come in three firmness options: medium soft (4), medium firm (6), and firm (7 or 8). The flagship model is the Brooklyn Signature Hybrid, which is made with Ascension pocketed coils and several types of foam to balance contouring and support.

Leesa offers four different mattress models with a more limited variety of sizes and firmness options. Each mattress rates as medium (5) or medium firm (6), which are two of the most popular firmness levels for sleepers of all body types. The Leesa Original Mattress is the company’s flagship product. It is an all-foam model designed for breathability, pressure relief, and support.

When choosing between Brooklyn Bedding and Leesa mattresses, there are several differences for you to consider, including your preferred firmness level, mattress size, and budget. We’ll examine the main mattress models by Brooklyn Bedding and Leesa, comparing construction, pricing, performance, policies, and other details that might be helpful in your decision-making process.

Sizing Options

Sizing is important when it comes to your mattress. A mattress that is too small might not have a large enough surface area to rest comfortably, but a mattress that is too big could take up too much space in your bedroom and unnecessarily increase the cost.

The height and weight of the mattress are often overlooked by shoppers, but these factors can also be important for long-term comfort. For example, a high-profile mattress could make getting in and out of bed easier for some people, like those with back or knee pain, but it may also make it more difficult for shorter individuals or those with a high bed frame. Additionally, high-profile models typically require deep pocket sheets in order to fit properly, so you might need new bedding.

Similarly, different mattress weights have potential pros and cons. For instance, a heavy mattress could be hard to move, but it may also be less prone to shifting if you toss and turn during the night.

There is no ideal size, height, and weight that will be ideal for all sleepers, so selecting the best option for you requires careful consideration of your priorities.

Leesa and Brooklyn Bedding both offer a variety of sizes. However, Brooklyn Bedding goes above and beyond to offer an exceptionally wide array, including unique sizes, like king RV, short full, full XL, short queen, and Olympic queen. The company can also produce custom sizes. Leesa makes the six standard mattress sizes, which should accommodate most buyers.

Brooklyn Bedding also provides a wider range of height options for their line of products, including high-profile models. The mattresses by both companies fall in a similar weight range, but Leesa produces the two lightest models of the lot.

Both companies make several distinct mattress models to meet varying needs and preferences. Whether you are searching for a lightweight mattress for greater movability or a specific mattress size to fit your space, you can browse each company’s models to find an option that suits your specific situation.

For example, if you need a quality mattress to fit in an RV, you may like the Brooklyn Aurora, the Brooklyn Bowery, the Brooklyn Bowery Hybrid, or the Brooklyn Signature. If you want the surface area of a queen size mattress but prefer a lightweight product, the Leesa Original or the Studio by Leesa may be good options.

When considering the size, height, and weight of your new mattress, we recommend taking your comfort into account as well as the size of the area where you plan to place your new mattress. It is always a good idea to take measurements of your space to make sure the product will fit well before making your purchase.

Construction and Materials Comparison

The materials and construction of a mattress can affect its durability and your overall comfort and sleep experience. Brooklyn Bedding and Leesa both offer all-foam and hybrid models, so shoppers should understand the differences between these two options for a clearer picture of which type of mattress they may prefer.

Hybrid mattresses typically use foam comfort layers and a coil core. This design often combines the contouring and pressure relief of a foam mattress with the bounce, breathability, and support of springs.

All-foam mattresses consist of one or more layers of foam, although some also contain other materials, like wool, cotton, or latex. All-foam mattresses usually reduce motion transfer and relieve pressure buildup.

Brooklyn Bedding

The Brooklyn Signature Hybrid is Brooklyn Bedding’s top-selling mattress. This hybrid bed is made with:

• Premium quilted top designed for cooling
• TitanFlex hyper-elastic polyfoam comfort layer, responsive VariFlex polyfoam transition layer (varies by firmness)
• Ascension pocketed coil core and high-density polyfoam base

The Signature Hybrid offers premium mattress features at an affordable price. Shoppers can select between soft, medium, and firm, which equate to medium soft (4), medium firm (6), and firm (8) respectively.

Each firmness option uses a quilted polyfoam top designed to mold to the body while resisting heat buildup. A TitanFlex polyfoam comfort layer (1.5 inches in the soft and medium models, 1 inch in the firm model) is designed to balance the conforming of memory foam and the responsiveness of latex. The soft and medium options use a 1-inch VariFlex transition layer, which has a similar blend of contouring and bounce. The firm version uses 2 inches of VariFlex foam as the transition layer for enhanced support.

The core consists of 8 inches of Ascension pocketed coils that give the bed its springy feel while letting air circulate. Sturdier coils around the perimeter enhance edge support. A final .25-inch layer of high-density polyfoam reinforces the coil system.

The Brooklyn Aurora Hybrid contains similar materials to the Signature but is designed with a focus on cooling technology. This mattress also features zoned coils to provide targeted support for lighter and heavier areas of the body. The Aurora’s components include:

• CopperFlex polyfoam comfort layer
• Surface infusion of TitanCool phase change material
• Secondary comfort layer of TitanFlex
• Gel-infused memory foam transition layer
• Zoned Ascension X coil and high-density polyfoam base

Like the Signature, the Aurora comes in three firmness levels that correspond to medium soft (4), medium firm (6), and firm (7).

This model contains five layers. First, a 1.5-inch layer of CopperFlex polyfoam is engineered for responsiveness and contouring. The surface infusion of TitanCool phase change material is designed to regulate the surface temperature. Next, a 2-inch comfort layer of TitanFlex polyfoam adds to the bed’s responsive feel. A 1-inch memory foam transition layer provides deep compression support while contouring to the shape of the body, and a gel infusion is designed to combat heat retention.

The core consists of 8 inches of zoned Ascension X pocketed coils for reactivity and airflow. A 1-inch base of high-density polyfoam supports the coils as they compress. The cover encasing the mattress includes a cooling top panel designed for additional temperature control.

The Brooklyn Spartan Hybrid uses the same basic design and materials as the Aurora Hybrid. What separates them is the Spartan Hybrid’s cover, which uses a smart fabric designed with far infrared rays technology intended to promote recovery and aid quality sleep.

The Brooklyn Sedona Hybrid is designed for luxury, so it comes at a higher price tag. This hybrid mattress uses:

• Woven top knit cooling panel
• Polyfoam comfort layer
• Two layers of gel-infused memory foam
• Polyfoam transition layer
• Ascension X coil system and high-density polyfoam base

The Sedona Hybrid has a medium feel. It consists of multiple layers meant to provide support, comfort, and cooling.

The bed is topped with a woven knit panel designed for temperature control. Next, a 1-inch layer of polyfoam acts as the top comfort layer, balancing contouring and responsiveness. The next two layers measure 2 inches and 1 inch, and each uses gel-infused memory foam designed to provide cradling, support, and cooling. A 1-inch polyfoam transition layer separates the comfort system from the 8-inch Ascension X coil core that gives the bed bounce and breathability. The 1-inch high-density polyfoam base supports coil compression.

The Brooklyn Bloom Hybrid includes several natural materials, making it a popular choice with eco-conscious shoppers. This hybrid model contains:

• Quilted Joma Wool and cotton cover
• Natural Talalay latex comfort layer
• Ascension X coil system and high-density polyfoam base

This bed uses more natural materials than Brooklyn Bedding’s other main models without sacrificing the company’s affordable pricing structure. The Bloom Hybrid has a medium firm (6) feel.

A 1.25-inch quilted cotton and Joma Wool cover cushions the surface of the bed while wicking away heat and moisture. The comfort layer uses 3 inches of natural Talalay latex that adjusts to the sleeper’s body and springs back to its original shape when the sleeper moves. An 8-inch Ascension X coil core gives the bed bounce without contributing to excessive motion transfer, and ample airflow through this layer helps heat dissipate. A 1-inch high-density polyfoam base bolsters the spring system.

The Brooklyn Bowery is an economical mattress choice that is available in all-foam and hybrid versions.

The all-foam version consists of:

• Energex polyfoam comfort layer
• Polyfoam transition layer
• High-density polyfoam base

The hybrid version includes:

• Quilted gel memory foam comfort layer
• Polyfoam transition layer
• Ascension coil core with high-density polyfoam base

Both Brooklyn Bowery options are medium firm (6), but they vary slightly in construction and performance.

The all-foam version uses three layers: a 3-inch Energex polyfoam comfort layer for pressure relief and responsiveness, a 2-inch polyfoam transition layer to act as a barrier between the comfort system and the firm core, and a 5-inch high-density polyfoam base for support.

Four layers make up the Brooklyn Bowery Hybrid. The comfort layer is quilted with 1 inch of gel memory foam designed to hug the body while transferring away heat. Next, a 2-inch polyfoam transition layer helps prevent the sleeper from sinking in against the core. Finally, a 6-inch layer of Ascension coils enhances the bed’s springiness and air circulation, and a 1-inch high-density polyfoam base provides an even plane for the coils to rest on.

Leesa

The Leesa Original Mattress is the company’s flagship product. It features the following materials:

• Breathable twill cover
• Responsive polyfoam comfort layer
• Transition layer of memory foam
• Supportive polyfoam base

This all-foam mattress was created with temperature management in mind, so it is a good option for shoppers who want the hug of foam without a lot of heat retention. The Leesa Original has a medium (5) feel that’s especially appropriate for side sleepers and individuals who weigh under 130 pounds.

Three layers give the Leesa Original its distinct feel. The comfort layer users 2 inches of polyfoam to cradle the body while allowing heat to escape. A 2-inch memory foam transition layer adds deeper contouring to ease pressure around the hips and shoulders. High-density polyfoam makes up the 6-inch support core, and a breathable twill fabric cover encases the mattress.

The Leesa Sapira Hybrid Mattress is designed to provide supportive comfort. This hybrid bed is made using:

• Hole-punched polyfoam comfort layer
• Secondary layer of memory foam
• Supportive polyfoam transition layer
• Pocketed coil core
• Supportive polyfoam base

This model uses a five-layer design. The top comfort layer is 1.5 inches of polyfoam that is ventilated with holes so that heat can escape. A second comfort layer with 1.5 inches of memory foam adds close-conforming pressure relief. The transition layer uses 1 inch of high-density polyfoam to reduce the likelihood of the sleeper pressing against the springs.

The 6-inch coil core uses individually encased 14.5-gauge springs to give the bed bounce, allow airflow, limit motion transfer, and give the bed a sturdier edge. It rests on a 1-inch base layer of high-density polyfoam for support. The mattress is encased in a soft, breathable cover.

This mattress is slightly more expensive than the Leesa Original and has a medium firm (6) feel.

The Leesa Legend Mattress is the company’s luxury model. This hybrid mattress uses a six-layer construction with

• Top comfort layer of hole-punched polyfoam
• Contouring memory foam layer
• Polyfoam and pocketed microcoil layer
• Transition layer of polyfoam
• Pocketed spring core with full perimeter support
• Supportive polyfoam base

This model uses a unique six-layer design with two coil systems. The bed’s top comfort layer is 1 inch of polyfoam that is aerated to allow cooling airflow. A second comfort layer uses 1 inch of memory foam to relieve pressure. The final 1.5-inch layer in the comfort system contains pocketed microcoils at the head and foot of the bed and polyfoam in the center to reinforce the midsection and promote good sleep posture.

The 6-inch 15-gauge coil core gives the bed a springy feel, good edge support, and extra temperature control. A 1-inch polyfoam layer rests on either side of the coil core to separate it from the comfort system and provide support. The bed is encased in a hypoallergenic cover made with polyester, recycled PES, cotton, merino wool, rayon, and spandex. The addition of wool enhances the bed’s ability to wick away moisture and regulate surface temperatures.

Since the Leesa Legend uses springs made from recycled steel and a cover made partially of recycled water bottles, it may appeal to environmentally conscious shoppers.

The Legend Mattress is available in one firmness level: medium firm (6).

The Studio by Leesa is the company’s most affordable mattress thanks to its pared-down design. This all-foam model uses:

• Comfort layer of responsive memory Polyfoam transition layer
• Supportive high-density polyfoam core

This mattress is a good option for people who pressure relief but are on a budget. It has a medium firm (6) feel that’s likely to feel especially comfortable to side sleepers.

The simple design starts with a 1.5-inch memory foam comfort layer that molds to the body to redistribute weight. Next, a 1.5-inch polyfoam transition layer lets the sleeper sink in a little more deeply for extra pressure relief. The 7-inch high-density polyfoam core supports the surface to limit sagging.

Mattress Performance Ratings

While mattresses that use similar materials may seem indistinguishable to some shoppers, there are many differences to consider. Your new mattress’s performance will affect both your sleep and your wallet. Mattress performance can be broken down into several categories, including ease of movement, pressure relief, and durability. Weighing performance criteria with your unique needs and desires may make it easier to find your ideal mattress.

• Durability: Durability refers to how long a mattress is likely to last based on its materials and construction. Most models will need to be replaced every 7 to 10 years. Low-quality materials and poor construction may lead to sagging or indentations that limit the usable lifespan of the mattress, while quality components and good designs may extend the life of the bed.
• Motion Isolation: The motion isolation rating measures the bed’s ability to keep one sleeper’s movements from affecting another person sleeping on the other side of the bed. Couples often prioritize motion isolation in their mattress purchasing decisions. For restless sleepers or couples on different sleep schedules, motion isolation can be especially useful.
• Sex: Some bed designs and materials are more favorable to intimacy than others. Mattresses that are very soft or hug closely to the body can hinder movement, so many couples prefer springier surfaces. Because of this, models with coil cores usually receive higher marks for sex than all-foam models.
• Temperature Neutrality: If your mattress retains warmth or restricts airflow, you may overheat during the night. Memory foam is especially prone to trapping heat because of its close hug, but special modifications can counteract this effect. Many models promote temperature neutrality through air circulation and special materials engineered for cooling.
• Pressure Relief: When a mattress adjusts to the shape of the sleeper’s body to spread out their weight more evenly, it’s said to have pressure relief. This is usually most important for side sleepers, who often suffer from pain related to pressure buildup near their shoulders and hips. Ideally, a mattress should also provide the right amount of support to help the sleeper maintain proper spinal alignment.Consumers who prefer notable pressure relief often look for models with memory foam since the material’s close-conforming limits pressure accumulation.
• Off-gassing: When a new mattress is removed from its packaging, it may release an odor, which is known as off-gassing. The smell is usually caused by volatile organic compounds (VOCs), which are created in the manufacturing process and escape as a mattress decompresses. Fortunately, the odor usually fades quickly, sometimes within just a few hours. Synthetic foam mattresses usually have a stronger smell than those made of other materials, but the odor should not be harmful to most consumers.
• Ease of Movement: Ease of movement refers to how easy it is to change positions or move across the surface of the bed. Memory foam can limit movement because it usually hugs closely to the body and is slower to regain its shape. This may feel restrictive to some sleepers, especially those who suffer from mobility issues or who tend to toss and turn. Firmer models with coil cores usually earn the highest scores in this category.
• Edge Support: The edges are often the weakest points of the bed, frequently sagging under pressure. If a mattress has good edge support, it will feel more stable when you sit on the edge of your bed, thereby making more of the mattress surface fully usable. Firm mattresses, models with coil cores, and beds with built-in edge reinforcement usually have the most supportive perimeters.

Brooklyn Bedding

Leesa

Pricing Information

Mattresses vary quite a bit in their pricing. The cost of your new mattress will be affected by its design, materials, size, thickness, and overall quality. If the mattress was made in the U.S., that could also factor in since labor and facilities may cost the company more.

Natural, organic, and/or proprietary components often come with higher price tags. Larger sizes and thicker models with more layers are also usually more expensive than smaller beds or mattresses with fewer layers. Basically, if a mattress costs the manufacturer more to make, customers should also expect to pay more.

You may balk at paying a higher price up front, but you should consider the long-term potential of the mattress to assess its overall value. A well-made mattress should be more durable, which may be worth the expense in the long run. You may also enjoy a better night’s sleep since high-quality materials often enhance a mattress’s performance.

Leesa and Brooklyn Bedding both offer everything from economy to luxury models with several options between the two extremes. Thanks to their wide selections, both of these companies provide beds at price-points likely to fit most budgets.

With a variety of price-points and mattresses available, most shoppers should be able to find a Brooklyn Bedding or Leesa model that suits their lifestyle, sleeping needs, and budget. Hybrid beds are often more expensive than all-foam models, and this tendency is reflected in the pricing structures of both companies.

Brooklyn Bedding produces more models than Leesa in a wider range of prices. As such, Brooklyn Bedding offers both the most affordable and the most expensive mattress by either brand. However, the flagship models by the two companies fall into a very similar price range.

The prices for mattresses by Brooklyn Bedding and Leesa are fairly typical compared to competitors with similar quality, materials, and designs. The two companies’ prices are comparable enough to make either one a good choice depending on the buyer’s needs and preferences.

Additionally, all the above mattresses are compressed, boxed, and shipped to the customer’s door. No additional shipping costs apply for buyers in the contiguous United States.

Trials, Warranty, and Delivery

Shipping

There are two main ways that companies ship mattresses:

• Both Leesa and Brooklyn Bedding use the mattress-in-a-box method for shipping. The company compresses the mattress, places it into a box, and ships it directly to your door. Once your mattress arrives, you relocate it to your room of choice, remove it from the box, and decompress it. Mattress-in-a-box shipping is often free.
• Some buyers prefer a White Glove delivery of their mattress, which means the bed is delivered to your home by a team. They will carry the mattress to your preferred location and set it up for you. You can also often elect to have your old mattress removed at this time. Leesa offers in-home and White Glove delivery as a shipping option, but it comes at an extra charge.

Brooklyn Bedding Shipping Policies

Brooklyn Bedding ships their beds within the U.S. and Canada. Shipping is free within the contiguous U.S. Charges apply for orders to Hawaii, Alaska, and Canada. White Glove delivery is not available.

Brooklyn Bedding typically ships via FedEx or UPS. The mattresses are made-to-order and shipped from Phoenix, AZ. Customers will receive tracking information when their order ships.

Leesa Shipping Policies

Leesa offers free shipping via FedEx within the United States. Select products also ship to Canada. Leesa will send you a tracking number for your package when the order ships.

Customers can also choose in-home delivery during the ordering process for an additional fee. Your mattress will be shipped to one of Leesa’s in-home delivery partners who will contact you to set up a time to deliver it and set it up. Old mattress removal is also available with this service.

Sleep Trial and Returns

Purchasing a bed online can be intimidating since you might not be able to feel it before it arrives in your home. Most online mattress companies offer a trial period for that reason. If you are unhappy with your purchase, trial policies typically give you the option to return or exchange it. The length of the trial policy and the specific terms vary between companies, so customers who are concerned that they may not enjoy their new mattress should read the fine print before placing an order.

Brooklyn Bedding Sleep Trial and Return Policy

Brooklyn Bedding offers a 120-night sleep trial for its mattresses. Within the 120-night trial period, you can exchange your mattress or return it for a full refund of the purchase price.

You must try the mattress for at least 30 days before you are eligible for a return. It can take some time to adjust to a new mattress, so this policy ensures that you have time to give it a thorough trial before deciding it’s not right for you. If the firmness of the mattress is not ideal for you, Brooklyn Bedding also offers to provide a topper. The 120-night sleep trial can only be used once per customer per year.

Leesa Sleep Trial and Return Policy

Every Leesa mattress includes a 100-night sleep trial to allow you to try out the mattress at home. This policy applies to your first Leesa mattress purchase. Return customers are not eligible.

Within your 100-night trial, you can return your clean, undamaged mattress for a refund. However, you must try the mattress for at least 30 nights so that your body can adjust before initiating the return. Leesa will pick up your discarded mattress from your home and provide a refund.

A $100 fee applies for mattresses returned in Alaska or Hawaii.

Warranty

A mattress can be expensive, so a generous warranty policy can give customers peace of mind that they’re protected if the product is defective. Most mattresses come with a warranty, but they vary in their length and coverage. Additional terms and conditions apply, so read the policy carefully.

Brooklyn Bedding Mattress Warranty

Brooklyn Bedding provides a 10-year limited warranty on its mattresses. At the company’s discretion, the warranty provides the replacement or repair of products with eligible defects, which include deterioration in the foam’s cell structure, cracking or splitting foam, impressions over 1 inch, and sagging.

This policy applies to the original owner and does not cover damage due to abuse, misuse, or the use of an improper foundation. Mattresses must have been decompressed within 60 days and be free from stains. The company also reserves the right to refuse replacement or repair if the mattress is deemed to be in unsanitary condition.

Leesa Mattress Warranty

All Leesa mattresses include a 10-year limited warranty. The warranty considers defects to include deterioration of the mattress and physical flaws in the craftsmanship of the mattress or cover, such as indentations greater than 1 inch and issues with the cover seaming and zipper.

Damage due to abuse, misuse, and the use of an improper foundation are not covered. If Leesa confirms that a qualifying defect exists, it will choose to either repair or replace the mattress.

Only the original owner can make claims, and they will be responsible for the shipping costs associated with the repair or replacement of their mattress.

Still have questions? Ask our community!

Join our Sleep Care Community — a trusted hub of product specialists, sleep health professionals, and people just like you. Whether you’re searching for the perfect mattress or need expert sleep advice, we’ve got you covered. Get personalized guidance from the experts who know sleep best.