Brooklyn Bedding vs. Casper Mattress Comparison

Overall Rating

8.4

Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid

Bottom Line

An affordable hybrid available in three firmness options. Tested well in most categories including pressure relief and temperature regulation.

Check Price on Brooklynbedding.com

25% off storewide/sitewide. Code: GIFT25

Full Mattress Review

VS

Overall Rating

7.6

Casper Original Mattress

Bottom Line

One of the most iconic bed-in-a-box mattresses, the Casper is an affordable all-foam bed with a medium-firm feel.

Check Price on Casper.com

Up to 60% off at Casper

Full Mattress Review

Brooklyn Bedding and Casper are two of the preeminent mattress-in-a-box companies. Each company produces multiple models, including hybrid and all-foam options. Both companies also sell sleep accessories, like pillows, sheets, blankets, and foundations.

There are several models in Brooklyn Bedding’s mattress line, including the Brooklyn Signature Hybrid, the Brooklyn Aurora Luxe, the Brooklyn Bedding Essential, the Brooklyn Spartan Hybrid, and Brooklyn Sedona Elite. The company offers other all-foam and hybrid mattresses, but this comparison guide will focus on the five aforementioned models.

Casper produces five mattress models: the Casper One, Casper Dream Hybrid, Casper Dream Max, Casper Snow Hybrid, and Casper Snow Max. The Casper One is an all-foam model, while the other four models are foam hybrids.

Brooklyn Bedding’s mattress models come in a wide range of firmness options. Its options are medium soft (4), medium firm (6), and firm (8). These firmness options can accommodate the vast majority of side and back sleepers, regardless of their weight. Casper mattress models firmness options are medium soft (4), medium (5), and medium firm (6). This mid-level firmness range is suitable for most individuals.

While Casper and Brooklyn Bedding mattresses have some similarities, several differences may influence your purchase decision. This review will cover each brand’s sizing, construction, pricing, performance, and policies to help you decide which company’s mattresses may be best for you.

Sizing Options

A mattress’s weight and size play a role in the convenience, sleep experience, and how well the mattress fits in your space.

Heavier mattresses may be harder to move around and set up, but they also often feel more secure since they are less likely to move when you change positions. Lighter mattresses are generally easier to move and rotate, but they might not feel as securely anchored on the foundation.

Thicker mattresses often have more support for sleepers who weigh over 230 pounds thanks to their thicker leyers. However, low-profile models are often less expensive. The profile may also affect how easy it is to get into or out of bed. A high-profile mattress on a tall frame may be challenging for shorter individuals to climb into. A low-profile mattress on a short frame may be equally challenging for some people.

The size of the mattress impacts how well it spits into your space and what size of foundation it requires. It can also influence the sleep experience, especially for couples. Couples usually prefer queen, king, or California king sizes so that they have more room to move around and don’t experience as much motion transfer.

Brooklyn Bedding offers a wider array of mattress options than Casper. Many Brooklyn Bedding mattresses are also available in multiple firmness levels, whereas all five Casper models are sold in one firmness only.

The mattresses by both companies come in similar height options. Both brands’ thinnest options measure between 10 and 11 inches. Casper’s thickest models are the 14-inch Dream Max and Snow Max, while the Aurora Luxe at 13.25 inches and the Sedona Elite at 14 inches are Brooklyn Bedding’s thickest models.

Brooklyn Bedding and Casper produce mattresses in the six standard sizes. Casper models are also available in a split king size intended for couples who share adjustable beds. Some Brooklyn Bedding models like the Signature Hybrid, Aurora Luxe, and Sedona Elite are sold in additional sizes such as split California king and RV-friendly options.

Construction and Materials Comparison

Mattresses typically contain at least one type of the most common materials. These include foam, latex, and coils. Each material has pros and cons that can affect your sleep experience. Understanding the materials may make it easier to select the best mattress for you.

There are two main types of foam: memory foam and polyfoam. Memory foam conforms closely to the sleeper’s body, but it frequently does not respond as quickly to changes in pressure as most other materials. Additionally, memory foam is often prone to heat retention, though many mattress models now have cooling features to combat this.

Polyfoam tends to be more breathable than memory foam and usually regains its shape more quickly, but it usually doesn’t have the same hugging sensation as memory foam. Low-density polyfoam also tends to break down more quickly.

Some mattresses use synthetic or natural latex in their construction. While this material is also formed into a foam, it is classified separately from memory foam and polyfoam due to its unique characteristics. Latex tends to be quite durable and breathable. It also has a more buoyant feel than most other foams. Like other types of foam, it relieves pressure. However, it doesn’t have the same hug. Many people feel they sleep “on” rather than “in” latex mattresses.

Innerspring and hybrid models use coil support systems. Coils add bounce and breathability, but they sometimes also contribute to noise and motion transfer. High-quality coils tend to be quite durable.

Brooklyn Bedding

Brooklyn Bedding’s mattress line consists of all-foam and foam hybrid models. Each mattress has a unique construction to provide distinct sleep experiences.

The Brooklyn Signature Hybrid

The Signature is a hybrid model intended to provide a premium feel at a budget-friendly price. It starts out with a quilted cover to provide cushioning. Next, a layer of a proprietary latex-like polyfoam called TitanFlex is crafted to contour to the body while responding quickly to changes in movement. This layer has a gel infusion to help pull heat away from the sleeper’s body.

A transition layer of VariFlex polyfoam gives deep compression support while acting as a barrier between the comfort and support systems. The support core uses 8 inches of pocketed coils, which give bounce and breathability while limiting motion transfer. A final .25-inch base layer of polyfoam supports the coil system.

The Brooklyn Aurora Luxe

The Aurora is a luxury hybrid model with advanced cooling technology. Its woven cover includes a phase-change material engineered to keep the sleeper’s skin temperature at 88 degrees. A 1.5-inch layer of patented polyfoam includes infusions of phase-change material and copper to wick heat away from the body and regulate the temperature of the sleep surface. Below that, there is a second comfort layer made up of 2 inches of latex-like polyfoam. This layer adjusts to the sleeper’s body and regains its shape quickly when pressure is removed.

A 1-inch transition layer of memory foam contours more deeply. It also has a gel infusion for additional cooling. The core is made up of 8-inches of coils, which are divided into zones to ensure adequate support for your torso and hips and gentler cradling for lighter parts of the body. This support system gives the bed a springy feel and allows significant airflow. Each coil is encased individually to decrease motion transfer. A 1-inch layer of polyfoam acts as a base for the coils.

The Brooklyn Essential

The Essential is Brooklyn Bedding’s budget hybrid model. Its design consists of two polyfoam comfort layers over a pocketed coil system. The feel is medium firm (6). This model won’t contour as closely to the body as Brooklyn’s thicker, plusher models, but its tried-and-true foam hybrid construction is a solid choice that’s easy on your wallet. The Essential is also a good match for children and teenagers.

The Brooklyn Spartan

The Spartan is a hybrid model with advanced technology engineered to promote recovery. Its cover is made of smart fabric crafted to reflect the sleeper’s natural energy back towards them to help enhance sleep quality and aid recovery. The top comfort layer uses 1.5 inches of polyfoam infused with copper and a phase-change material. This layer contours to the body, while its infusions help neutralize the temperature of the sleep surface. A second comfort layer with 2 inches of latex-like polyfoam combines cradling and responsiveness.

A 1-inch memory foam transition layer with a gel swirl further adds to the cooling and contouring. The core uses 8 inches of pocketed coils. The encasement of the coils limits the spread of motion across the layer. These coils also add bounce and breathability, while a 1-inch polyfoam base supports them.

The Brooklyn Sedona Elite

Brooklyn Bedding’s luxury hybrid model is the Sedona Elite, which is constructed with comfort layers of polyfoam and gel-infused memory foam encased in a Euro-top cover. The support core consists of 8-inch pocketed coils and high-density base foam. GlacioTex phase change fabric — a material engineered to dissipate body heat on contact — encases the mattress. The Sedona Elite is medium (5), so it’s a bit plusher than many of Brooklyn Bedding’s other offerings.

Casper

Casper has five main models, which include one all-foam option and four hybrids.

The Casper One

The Casper One is Casper’s all-foam model. Its comfort system features layers of open-cell polyfoam and memory foam. The open cell structure of the polyfoam layer promotes airflow and reduces heat buildup on the surface, while the memory foam layer is intended to contour closely and alleviate pressure points along the spine. A support core of high-density polyfoam stabilizes the mattress and reinforces the medium firm (6) feel.

The Casper Dream Hybrid and Dream Max

The Casper Dream Hybrid is constructed with polyfoam and memory foam comfort layers and a pocketed coil support core. The memory foam is zoned, meaning it feels more supportive beneath your torso and hips to compensate for the extra weight in these areas of the body.

The Dream Hybrid is medium (5), so the mattress contours rather closely to your body. You can upgrade to the Casper Dream Max, which adds a third foam layer to the comfort system and makes the surface feel plusher. That said, we’ve also rated the Dream Max as medium (5) based on how closely the mattress conforms to your body.

The Casper Snow Hybrid and Snow Max

Casper’s Snow Hybrid is a luxury model created with extra cooling in mind. The first layer consists os memory foam coated in phase change material, which helps minimize heat retention to keep you cool. Proprietary “HeatDelete” bands dissipate body heat from the surface for added temperature control.

The standard Snow Hybrid also contains two memory foam comfort layers, the first of which is zoned to provide extra pushback around your midsection. As with the Dream Hybrid and Dream Max, you can upgrade your Snow Hybrid to the Snow Max and add a third memory foam layer to its comfort system. The Snow Hybrid is medium (5), and the noticeably plusher Snow Max is medium soft (4).

In-Depth Ratings

Several aspects and features are particularly important to take into consideration as you select a mattress. These factors can impact how comfortable you feel on a mattress, how well you sleep, and more. Each individual is likely to prioritize some aspects and features over others, so we recommend you focus on these factors when considering a mattress.

• Durability: A mattress’s durability is a result of its materials and construction. Less durable mattresses are frequently more affordable. However, high-quality mattresses may ultimately be a better value since they often have longer lifespans.
• Motion Isolation: Motion isolation is often a high priority for couples. When one partner moves, the mattress may either transfer these vibrations across the surface of the bed or absorb them. A mattress that isolates motion well may reduce sleep disturbances for couples, which may be particularly important for people who tend to wake up easily during the night.
• Sex: Some mattresses are more conducive to amorous activity than others. Couples frequently prefer a springy, responsive bed for sex. While they may like some conforming for traction, a mattress with a lot of hug and minimal bounce could restrict movement and make couples feel trapped in the bed.
• Temperature Neutrality: Sleepers who tend to overheat during the night may prefer a mattress with strong temperature regulation. Some mattresses include special features to improve air circulation and cool the sleep surface, while others may trap heat against the sleeper’s body. Memory foam is particularly prone to heat retention, but many mattresses that use memory foam have additional features to help neutralize the temperature.
• Pressure Relief: Certain body parts put more force on a mattress, and this can lead to pressure points. Mattresses with good contouring tend to spread out the sleeper’s weight more evenly to reduce the pressure buildup that often occurs near the hips and shoulders. Strong pressure relief may be particularly important for people who suffer from aches and pains.
• Off-gassing: Off-gassing refers to the initial odor the mattress emits when it is first unpacked. Many mattresses ship compressed, so manufacturing odors could be trapped inside and may release as the mattress decompresses in your home. Synthetic foam tends to have more manufacturing odors than many materials. While these smells are generally considered harmless for most people and usually air out within a few days, shoppers who are sensitive to smells may prefer a mattress less prone to off-gassing.
• Ease of Movement: If you change positions frequently during the night or you have a condition that limits your mobility, you might prefer a mattress that is easy to move on. Mattresses that have a lot of hug or sinkage may limit motion for some individuals. This is especially true if the materials are slow to respond to changes in pressure, which is common with memory foam. When a mattress is close conforming and slow responding, some sleepers may feel like they need to escape their own body impression to change positions.
• Edge Support: A sturdy edge can expand the usable surface of the mattress by allowing sleepers to lie near the perimeter of the bed. When the edge of the mattress feels unstable, sleepers may gravitate towards the center of the bed to feel more secure. Couples who need the extra room, individuals who like to lie near the perimeter of the bed, and anyone who frequently sits on the edge of the bed may prefer a model with good edge support.

Brooklyn Bedding

Casper

In-Depth Pricing

Mattress models come in a wide range of price points, starting at a few hundred dollars and going to upwards of $3,000. A mattress is a big investment, and selecting the right mattress can help you get the best night’s sleep possible. However, the mattress’s price may be one of the deciding factors that influences your purchasing decision.

Materials are usually the biggest factor in mattress pricing. Some materials are more expensive, and this cost is passed on to consumers. For instance, natural latex is usually more expensive than synthetic foam. Additionally, mattresses with advanced materials frequently carry a higher price tag due to the expense of developing the technology. Because thicker mattresses and larger mattress sizes use more of the materials, customers can also expect them to cost more.

Where the mattress and materials are manufactured can also influence the price. Labor costs in the United States tend to be higher, so American-made mattresses are often more expensive.

Brooklyn Bedding and Casper mattresses come in a fairly wide range of price points, but there are some notable differences between their pricing.

Brooklyn Bedding

Casper

The mattress models by Brooklyn Bedding and Casper come in a fairly wide range of price points. Both companies offer budget-friendly options and premium models. While their mattresses come in a similar price range, Casper has options that are both lower and higher in price than any of Brooklyn Bedding’s models.

The Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid and Casper One are the cheapest offerings from each respective company, while the Brooklyn Bedding Sedona Elite and Casper Snow Hybrid/Snow Max are considered luxury models. Other mattresses from both brands are considered mid-range in terms of pricing.

The price difference between the two brands is primarily due to the mattress materials and construction. Since this price difference is not significant, mattress models by either Brooklyn Bedding or Casper may have an edge for some individuals based on their personal preferences.

Trial, Warranty, and Delivery

Shipping

Brooklyn Bedding
Brooklyn Bedding ships mattresses for free within the contiguous United States. Mattresses are delivered by FedEx and usually arrive within 3 or 4 business days.

The company also ships to Alaska, Hawaii, and Canada for additional charges. Fees start at $125 per mattress for orders to Alaska and Hawaii and $250 per mattress for orders to Canada.

Mattresses ship from Phoenix, AZ. They are compressed, wrapped in plastic, and packaged in a box. Brooklyn Bedding suggests that two people work together to move the mattress into their house and set it up.

Casper
Casper mattresses ship free within the contiguous United States. Additional shipping charges apply to orders to Alaska, Hawaii, and Canada. Casper also sells mattresses in Austria, Germany, Switzerland, and the United Kingdom.

Mattresses shipped within the contiguous United States typically ship via UPS. Most mattresses ship 1-2 business days after the order is placed. The customer can elect at checkout whether or not to have their signature required for delivery. Otherwise, the mattress will be left outside their door. The mattress arrives compressed, wrapped in plastic, and encased in a box.

Casper also offers In-Home Delivery and Setup within most of the contiguous United States for an additional charge of $149. This option may also be available in large cities in Canada. With this service, Casper’s delivery partner will bring the mattress into your house, set it up, and remove the packaging. You can also opt to have your old mattress removed if it is in sanitary condition. In-Home Delivery and Setup charges are non-refundable.

Same-day delivery is available in some parts of New York City and Los Angeles.

Sleep Trial

Brooklyn Bedding
Brooklyn Bedding mattresses come with a 120-night sleep trial. The company requires that customers try the mattress for at least 30 nights before initiating a return. If they are not satisfied with their mattress during the eligible window, customers can contact Brooklyn Bedding for solutions. The company may work with the customer to modify the mattress, help the customer ensure the mattress has a proper foundation, or exchange the mattress for a different model (prices may vary).

If no solution can be found, customers can also return their mattress for a full refund of the purchase price. Customers are eligible for Brooklyn Bedding’s sleep trial once per calendar year.

Casper
Casper mattresses come with a 100-night sleep trial. The company recommends trying the mattress for at least 30 nights to adjust. If you choose to return your mattress during the trial period, Casper will arrange to pick up the mattress and issue a full refund of the purchase price. Returned mattresses are either donated or recycled. Customers are eligible for one trial period per product.

Other retailers may have their own return policies for the Casper mattresses they sell.

Warranty

Most mattress companies offer warranties as a layer of protection for the consumer. These warranties are usually included with the purchase price and protect against certain defects. Coverage varies between brands, but most warranties cover indentations over a certain measurement and cracking or splitting of the mattress’s foam.

When looking at a warranty, the customer should consider what defects are covered, how the company promises to resolve warranty claims, how long the warranty period is, what the customer’s responsibilities are, and what may void the warranty. Warranty policies vary a great deal, so reading the terms and conditions carefully can give you a clearer idea of how comprehensive the policy is.

Brooklyn Bedding
Brooklyn Bedding mattresses come with a 10-year warranty. The warranty covers deterioration or defects in the latex’s or polyfoam’s cell structure, defects that cause splitting or cracking, impressions of 1 inch or greater, and sagging. To qualify, the damage must not be the result of using an improper foundation. Brooklyn Bedding will either repair or replace mattresses with eligible defects.

Mattresses that have been subjected to abuse, misuse, staining, or unsanitary conditions are not eligible for warranty coverage. Additionally, mattresses left compressed for 60 days or longer are not covered.

This warranty is valid for the original mattress purchaser and is non-transferrable. Proof of purchase is required. Additional terms and conditions apply.

Casper
Casper mattresses come with a 10-year limited warranty that protects against indentations greater than 1 inch, flaws that lead to cracking or splitting in the foam, and defects in the cover’s zipper. If Casper determines a mattress has a qualifying defect, it will elect to either repair or replace the mattress.

This warranty covers the original mattress owner who purchased their Casper mattress from an authorized seller in the United States or Canada. It does not cover trade customers, mattresses used without a proper foundation, or mattresses that have been subjected to abuse or misuse.

The warranty is non-transferrable, and customers must provide proof of purchase. Additional terms and conditions apply.

Still have questions? Ask our community!

Join our Sleep Care Community — a trusted hub of product specialists, sleep health professionals, and people just like you. Whether you’re searching for the perfect mattress or need expert sleep advice, we’ve got you covered. Get personalized guidance from the experts who know sleep best.