Richard Simon, MD
I think doctors spend way too much time browbeating people about losing weight. We should be focusing on taking obese people and helping them to be fit. The way I approach obesity is to first advise regular exercise: walking 20–30 minutes a day at first, getting up to 2–3 hours a day, if possible. Although 20 minutes of exercise a day improves cardiovascular fitness, quite a bit more exercise is required to help with weight loss. We need more than 20 minutes a day to burn more calories. Once you have established a reasonable exercise base, then you can focus on losing weight through diet.
For the obese patient with OSA, first get the apnea treated. Get on CPAP. Then begin exercising and working on healthier eating habits. Unfortunately, we do not have great treatments for obesity that have long term success rates of much greater than 5–10%. Thus I prefer to start therapy with CPAP (70% success rate) and exercise (probably less than a 50% success rate).
Studies on the relationship between exercise and sleep are all over the map. Patients who are not physically fit and exercise within 6 hours of going to bed are likely to fragment their sleep, possibly because of aches and pains. I recommend exercise early in the day for patients who aren't physically fit.
For patients who are physically fit, the timing of the exercise generally doesn't make any difference. Interestingly, for physically fit patients, eliminating exercise often results in insomnia—but we don't know exactly why.
Many of my patients have severe sleep apnea, depression, and a variety of other conditions. Those who get out and exercise tend to feel better and accomplish more in the daytime. We've found that beneficial exercise is not only walking, but also weight lifting—especially for the elderly. The data on improving quality of life through exercise is better than the data on dieting.
-—Richard Simon, MD, is Medical Director of the